Episode III: Sadly, I Was On The Mark
Friday, May 6th, 2005oI knew I said the movie was going to be disastrous, but I was secretly really hoping it wouldn’t be. I was hoping to have some closure to a story that meant a lot to me as a child and all I got was massive disappointment.
It was a colossal failure on almost every level.
It was literally laughable, the audience howled at moments that were supposed to be dead serious or have some sort of emotional gravitas. The actor that played Senator Palpatine, was just horrendous. Not that Star Wars has ever been known for it’s great acting, but he brought badness to new heights.
It’s much more than the bad dialogue and the bad acting, it’s the bad direction which is something that’s hard to qualify. Lucas doesn’t know where to put his camera to get the maximum emotion or effect from a scene. He’s fine with action sequences, but those are basically handed off to ILM.
How am I disappointed after extensively noting how it wouldn’t be redeeming? Knowing something will suck and being disappointed by a story that was important to you as a kid are not mutually exclusive.
There’s so many moments that you just don’t buy at all. The way Anakin turns to the dark side is pathetic, you don’t believe it for a second. It has all the ingredients of a an incredible tragedy, stock, but on par with any Greek tragedy, but it’s presented and executed in a cliché-riddled and insipid manner.
This is also being generous. Anakin is supposed to be "seduced" by the Dark Side. In the movie it comes off as if his arm was slightly twisted and he goes, "Ah hell, ok, I’ll betray my principals and my ideals, what the hell."
Sure, it’s a Faustian pact he’s making to save his wife, but even then you don’t feel like there’s a lot of emotional investment. On paper, selling your soul to the devil to save your most beloved person in the world is so tragically romantic, but it has zero depth and zero emotional impact. You don’t feel sorry for him, you don’t buy that this was a tough gut-wrenching decision, again — it’s actors fufilling the obligations of a story in a totally anemic manner.
Also, the universe is apparently made up of 6 people. Of course Chewbacca is one of the Wookies in the Wookie army. Does Yoda really need to say his name when he looks exactly the same and dresses exactly the same as the original series? The answer, is apparently yes. How uncreative can you get? Things like this happen throughout. Apparently in a huge galaxy with thousands of planets, it’s still all six degrees of separation.
Is it the best one? I suppose if you took 3 pieces of dog shit and judged them by which turd smelt the least offensive, EPIII might win, but a dogshit is still dogshit.
I got interviewed by ABC news after I excited the theater and railed into it. The guy who interviewed me was shocked. He was like, "Wow, do you need a smoke?"